If you’re a pastor or ministry leader who’s noticed that the same handful of religious voices show up in every local news story — and most of them don’t share your theology, your politics, or your sense of what ministry is for — this post is for you. There’s a way to change that, and it doesn’t require being loud, doesn’t require a PR firm, and doesn’t require pretending to be someone you’re not. It mostly requires being useful.
Local journalists need sources. They need real people they can quote on deadline. And in most communities, the religious voices they have on speed dial are the ones who reached out first, made themselves easy to work with, and stayed available. That can be you.
The short version
- Local newsrooms are smaller than they used to be, and reporters are stretched thin.
- They rely on a small list of trusted, available, quotable sources — and most of those lists were built years ago.
- You can get on that list with a few low-effort introductions and a willingness to actually pick up the phone.
- The goal isn’t getting your church mentioned. It’s becoming a useful person for a reporter to know.
- Progressive ministry voices are underrepresented in most local coverage. There’s room.
Why this matters more than it used to
Local journalism in America has been hollowed out. Newsroom staffs are smaller. Reporters cover beats they don’t know well. Religion coverage in particular is often handed to a general assignment reporter who’s been told to file a story by 4:00 about a topic they know almost nothing about.
That reporter is going to call someone. They’re going to call whoever they can reach quickly, whoever sounds like they know what they’re talking about, and whoever made it easy for them to get a quote last time. If your name isn’t in their contacts, they’ll go with whoever is.
In most communities, that “whoever” skews toward whichever pastor was loudest a decade ago, plus a couple of well-established institutions. Progressive voices, ecumenical voices, Black church voices, women’s voices, and quiet-but-thoughtful voices are systematically underrepresented — not because reporters are biased, but because nobody from those communities ever introduced themselves.
Becoming a source isn’t self-promotion. It’s making sure the public conversation about religion and community in your town actually includes someone like you.
Step one: identify the reporters who matter
You don’t need to be on a first-name basis with every journalist in your region. You probably need to know about three to five.
Open your local paper’s website. Look at the bylines on stories about religion, faith communities, social services, education, local nonprofits, and community life. The same names will start appearing. Those are the reporters whose beats overlap with yours.
If your paper has a religion reporter, that’s the obvious first contact. If they don’t (most don’t anymore), the metro reporter, the community reporter, or whoever covers nonprofits or education is your most likely match.
Do the same scan for your local TV stations, public radio, and any community news websites or podcasts. Don’t forget the smaller outlets — neighborhood papers, alt-weeklies, and ethnic media often have more sustained relationships with communities of faith than the daily paper does.
Make a list of names, outlets, and what they tend to cover. Five names is plenty.
Step two: introduce yourself before you have an ask
This is where most pastors get it wrong. They never reach out until they want coverage of something — a building campaign, a special service, a controversy. By then it’s too late, because the reporter doesn’t know who you are.
Reverse it. Reach out before you have anything to pitch.
A short email works. Something like:
Subject: Introduction — Pastor at [Church Name]
Dear [Reporter’s First Name],
I’ve been reading your coverage of [a specific story they wrote], and I appreciated the way you handled [a specific detail]. I’m the pastor at [Church Name] in [neighborhood], and I wanted to introduce myself in case it’s ever useful to have a religious voice on a local story.
A few things I’d be glad to talk about on the record: [two or three areas, e.g., interfaith work in our community, how progressive churches are responding to X, the realities of small-church ministry in our area, our work on [issue]].
No need to reply unless something comes up — I just wanted you to have my number. I’m at [phone number] and usually responsive within a few hours during the workweek.
Thanks for the work you do covering this community.
[Your Name]
Three things make that email work. First, you mention a specific story they actually wrote (not generic “I love your work”). Second, you tell them what you can speak to, so they don’t have to guess. Third, you don’t ask for anything. You give them a contact and step out of the way.
Most reporters won’t reply. That’s fine. The point is that when they’re scrolling their inbox at 2:30 looking for a quote, your name is there.
Step three: be useful when they call back
Eventually one of them will. When that happens, three things matter more than anything else.
Pick up the phone, or call back fast. A reporter on deadline is racing the clock. If they can’t reach you in twenty minutes, they’re moving on to the next person. Set up a separate ringtone for unknown numbers if you have to. Returning a reporter’s call within the hour, every time, is the single biggest thing that distinguishes “person we sometimes call” from “person we always call.”
Be quotable. That doesn’t mean clever or dramatic. It means saying things in complete sentences that capture a real thought. Watch how the reporters you respect quote sources, and notice how short those quotes usually are. One or two clean sentences with a specific image or claim, not a five-minute meander. If you find yourself drifting, stop, take a breath, and say, “Let me try that again.” Reporters appreciate that — they know you’re trying to give them something useful.
Be honest about the limits of what you know. If they ask you something outside your wheelhouse, say so, and offer to point them to someone who knows more. “I can’t speak to that, but you should call Rev. Dr. So-and-so over at [other church] — she’s been working on this for fifteen years and she’ll know.” Reporters remember the people who help them find better sources almost as much as the people who give them quotes.
The reporter is not your adversary, and they’re not your friend. They’re a professional doing a hard job, and your job is to make their job a little easier without compromising your own integrity. If you do that consistently, you become indispensable.
What to watch out for
A few honest cautions, because pretending this is risk-free wouldn’t help you.
Don’t go off the record unless you really mean it. “Off the record” has different meanings to different reporters. Assume anything you say can be quoted unless you’ve explicitly negotiated otherwise before you say it, and even then, trust takes time to build. If you’re not ready for something to be public, don’t say it on the phone with a reporter.
Don’t make it about your church. When a reporter calls, your job is to be useful for the story, not to insert your church’s website into the quote. The pastors who get cited often are the ones whose comments are about the issue, not the marketing. Counterintuitively, that’s also how your church gets mentioned — by association, because you’re the one who said the thing worth printing.
Don’t take silence personally. You will give your best quote of the year and not see it printed. The reporter cut it for length, or the editor reshaped the story, or the news cycle moved on. None of that is about you. Keep showing up.
Be careful what you wish for, especially on hot-button issues. Once you’re known as a source on a controversial topic, that’s what you’ll be called about. If you’re prepared for that, fine. If you’re not, decline to comment publicly and offer background instead.
A small next step
This week, open your local paper’s website and identify two reporters whose beats overlap with the work of your church. Write down their names and what they tend to cover. Don’t email them yet. Just notice them.
Next week, send one short introduction email to one of them — the one whose work you most admire. Don’t ask for anything. Just put your number in their inbox.
That’s it. That’s the first move. The slow, quiet work of becoming someone the local newsroom actually calls starts with a single email that doesn’t ask for anything in return.
If posts like this are useful, you can get them in your inbox — subscribe to the Faithlab blog. No sales pitches, just practical help for church and nonprofit communicators.